Hardly Dark Ages

Short 02 · 1793–1893 · 2 min read

The Iron Maiden Isn't Medieval

The iron maiden is the most famous "medieval" torture device. It first shows up in 1793.

Younger than the French Revolution

The iron maiden is the most famous "medieval" torture device, and most people assume it belongs to the Middle Ages. Yet the first time it shows up is 1793, a few years after the French Revolution began in 1789. In other words, the iron maiden is younger than the French Revolution.

An iron maiden on display: a tall hollow figure with spikes on the inside
An iron maiden on display. It looks medieval, but its paper trail starts in 1793.Ivano Giambattista, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
Painting of the storming of the Bastille, with smoke rising over the fortress
The storming of the Bastille, 1789. The French Revolution came before the first mention of the iron maiden.Jean-Pierre Houël, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A guidebook and a claim

In 1793 a German writer, Johann Philipp Siebenkees, published a guidebook to Nuremberg. In it he claimed that the city had used an iron maiden in 1515 to execute a coin forger.

Historic view of Nuremberg in 1795 with a camp in the foreground and the city behind
Nuremberg in 1795: the camp of the citizens' cavalry company. Two years earlier, Siebenkees had published his guidebook to the city.Unknown artist (1795), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The problem: nobody has found a single record of that execution, and there is no evidence that such a device existed at the time. Historians think Siebenkees may simply have made it up. Medievalists.net calls the story likely invented, while Sky HISTORY says it is impossible to tell. Either way, nothing from 1515 backs the claim.

Put the dates side by side and the gap is striking. Between the execution Siebenkees described and the first time anyone wrote about it lie 278 years, with not a single record in between. A torture device that supposedly existed in the early 16th century leaves its first trace in a guidebook written at the end of the 18th.

Timeline graphic: the year 1515 stamped NO RECORD
The supposed execution of 1515: no record has ever been found.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

How a story became an object

True or not, the story sold. By the early 1800s, iron maidens were on display in Nuremberg and in other cities. Engravings like the one below showed a secret court and its spiked machine as if they were real history.

Engraving of a man forced to kneel in a dungeon before an open iron maiden
Engraving "Das heimliche Gericht mit der eisernen Jungfrau zu Nürnberg" (The secret court with the iron maiden of Nuremberg).Wellcome Collection, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (licence)

Once real objects stood in rooms where visitors could see them, the device gained a kind of authority that a single sentence in a guidebook never had. An iron maiden on display looked like evidence, even though nobody had shown that any of them dated back to the Middle Ages.

The fame spread far beyond Germany. One iron maiden even made it to the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago, a full century after Siebenkees first wrote about it.

Historic photograph of the Court of Honor at the World's Columbian Exposition, with white buildings around a long basin
The Court of Honor at the World's Columbian Exposition, the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago, where an iron maiden went on show.C. D. Arnold, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Timeline: 1515 claimed execution with no record, 1789 French Revolution, 1793 first mention in Siebenkees' guidebook, 1893 Chicago World's Fair
From a claimed execution with no record to a World's Fair exhibit.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)
Cruel BritanniaA secret history of torture in BritainAffiliate linkAmazon →

What became of the iron maidens

The Nuremberg iron maiden was destroyed in the Second World War. By then, historians already knew it was a fake. The sources disagree on the exact year of its destruction, so we do not give one.

And the one in Rothenburg ob der Tauber? The Medieval Crime Museum there says its iron maiden was used for public shaming, and that the spikes were added later. That is the museum's own account, and we report it as such. If it is right, the object was meant for shaming, and the spikes that make it look like a killing machine are a later addition.

The iron maiden in the Medieval Crime Museum in Rothenburg ob der Tauber
The iron maiden in Rothenburg. According to the Medieval Crime Museum, it was used for public shaming, and the spikes came later.User:Mattes, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

So the next time someone calls the iron maiden medieval, remember: as far as the evidence goes, it is younger than the French Revolution.

📚 Want more?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fact check 9 claims
First mention in 1793, in Siebenkees' guidebook to NurembergSky HISTORY ("published in 1793"); Medievalists.net (late 18th century, Nuremberg guidebook)
Claim: a coin forger was executed with it in Nuremberg in 1515Sky HISTORY
No contemporary evidenceSky HISTORY (no record of the execution, no evidence it existed)
Probably inventedMedievalists.net ("likely ... invented"); Sky HISTORY ("impossible to tell"), hence the script says "may simply have made it up"
On display in Nuremberg and other cities in the early 19th centuryMedievalists.net
One at the 1893 World's Fair in ChicagoMedievalists.net
The Nuremberg piece was destroyed in the Second World War; by then it was already known to be a fakeMedievalists.net (image caption)
Rothenburg: used for public shaming, spikes added laterRothenburg Tourism (Medieval Crime Museum page); presented in the script as the museum's own statement
The French Revolution came before 1793 (it began in 1789)General knowledge (Britannica)

Deliberately left out (evidence too thin): The exact year the Nuremberg iron maiden was destroyed (1944 or 1945, sources conflict), the date of 14 August, the "cloak of shame" (Schandmantel) theory (not supported by evidence), and possible ancient models.

Sources 3
  1. Medievalists.net, Why Medieval Torture Devices are Not Medieval
    https://www.medievalists.net/2023/12/medieval-torture-devices/
  2. Sky HISTORY, The Iron Maiden: Medieval torture device or modern myth?
    https://www.history.co.uk/articles/the-iron-maiden-medieval-torture-device-or-modern-myth
  3. Rothenburg ob der Tauber, Medieval Crime Museum
    https://www.rothenburg.de/en/entdecken/museen/mittelalterliches-kriminalmuseum