Hardly Dark Ages

Short 03 · 1304 · 2 min read

The King Who Refused a Surrender

In 1304, Stirling Castle tried to surrender. Edward I said not yet: he wanted to test his new siege engine first.

A surrender that came too early

In 1304, Edward I of England had Stirling Castle in Scotland under siege. At some point the Scottish garrison was ready to give up and offered to surrender. Normally that would have been the end of the story. Not this time.

Stirling Castle seen from a tower, in an old colour photochrom print
Stirling Castle, Scotland, in a photochrom print from the Library of Congress collection.Photochrom Print Collection (Library of Congress), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

As Medievalists.net puts it, the garrison commander Oliphant offered his surrender, "but Edward had not quite finished". The king had a new siege engine on site and he wanted to see it work. The garrison's offer was refused until the new machine had been tested, and only then was the surrender accepted.

Medieval drawing of King Edward I from an Exchequer memoranda roll
Edward I of England, drawn on an Exchequer memoranda roll (The National Archives).Unknown author (Exchequer roll, The National Archives), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The king's instructions, quoted by Medievalists.net, were blunt: no one was to enter the castle until it had been struck with the Warwolf. In other words, the castle was not allowed to surrender before it had been hit.

Seventeenth-century engraving of Stirling Castle on its rock
Stirling Castle as drawn by John Slezer in 1693.John Slezer (1693), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

What was the Warwolf?

The Warwolf was the name of Edward's new engine. What exactly it looked like is not settled by our sources, so we have to be careful. Medievalists.net says it is "usually assumed to have been a giant trebuchet", and that is the view most historians take. So when we call it a trebuchet, that is the most likely answer, not a certainty.

That caution matters. A good story tends to grow in the retelling, and the Warwolf is a very good story. Its core, though, is well supported: the siege took place in 1304, the garrison offered to give up, and the king held back the surrender until his engine had been tried. Medievalists.net quotes his instruction directly.

Medieval manuscript miniature showing men operating a trebuchet
A trebuchet in a 13th-century manuscript miniature, Morgan Library & Museum (cropped).Unknown author, 13th century (Morgan Library), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Counterweight trebuchet model kitSee the see-saw in action: build a wooden counterweight trebuchetAffiliate linkAmazon →

How a trebuchet works: a see-saw that hates you

A counterweight trebuchet is basically a giant see-saw. A long arm turns on a pivot. On the short end hangs a huge counterweight. On the long end there is a sling holding the stone. The name says it all: like a see-saw, one side goes down so the other side can go up, only here the side that goes up is carrying a rock aimed at your walls.

Diagram of a trebuchet at rest with labelled arm, pivot, counterweight and sling
The parts: a long arm on a pivot, a heavy counterweight on the short end and a sling with the stone on the long end.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

To fire it, the crew pulls the long end of the arm down, which lifts the counterweight into the air. Then they load the stone into the sling and let go.

Diagram of a trebuchet pulled down and loaded, counterweight raised
Loading: the long end is pulled down, the counterweight goes up and the sling is loaded.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

The weight drops, the arm whips up, and the sling flicks out like the end of a whip, flinging the stone. The sling matters: it effectively lengthens the lever, so the stone gets more out of the swing than the arm alone could give it. There is no gunpowder involved at all. The whole machine runs on gravity.

Diagram of a trebuchet throwing, counterweight falling and sling releasing the stone
The throw: the counterweight falls, the arm swings up and the sling releases the stone. No gunpowder, just gravity.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

What we left out, and why

Some details of this story are often repeated but disputed in the sources, so we kept them out. The exact date of the surrender is given as either 20 or 24 July. The size of the garrison is reported as 30, or as 50 or 120. We also left out specific ranges and weights for the Warwolf, the popular claim that it was the biggest trebuchet in history, and any description of how much damage it actually did.

What remains is solid enough: in 1304 a castle tried to surrender, and the king said: not yet.

📚 Want more?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fact check 5 claims
Edward I besieged Stirling Castle in 1304Medievalists.net (Santiuste, The Hammer of the Scots); Wikipedia, Siege of Stirling Castle (1304)
The garrison offered to surrender, but Edward was "not quite finished" and only accepted the surrender after the testMedievalists.net: "Oliphant offered his surrender, but Edward had not quite finished"; Wikipedia: refused until the Warwolf was tested
Order: no one was to enter the castle until it had been struck by the WarwolfMedievalists.net (quotes the king's instruction)
The Warwolf was probably a giant trebuchetMedievalists.net: "usually assumed to have been a giant trebuchet"
How it works: long arm, counterweight on the short end, sling on the long end; the sling lengthens the leverBritannica (search excerpt), USC Illumin, Scientific American (Chevedden 1995)

Deliberately left out (evidence too thin): The exact date of the surrender (20 vs. 24 July), the size of the garrison (30 vs. 50/120), specific ranges and weights, the claim that the Warwolf was "the largest trebuchet in history", and the damage the Warwolf actually caused.

Sources 3
  1. Medievalists.net, The Hammer of the Scots: Edward I and the Scottish Wars of Independence
    https://www.medievalists.net/2015/05/the-hammer-of-the-scots-edward-i-and-the-scottish-wars-of-independence/
  2. Encyclopaedia Britannica, Trebuchet
    https://www.britannica.com/technology/trebuchet
  3. P. E. Chevedden et al., The Trebuchet, Scientific American 273 (July 1995)