Hardly Dark Ages

Short 05 · 1203–1204 · 2 min read

The Castle That Fell Through the Toilet

Richard the Lionheart built a super-castle. It had one weak spot: the toilet.

Richard's castle and the siege of 1203

Château Gaillard was built by Richard the Lionheart in the 1190s, between 1196 and 1198, at Les Andelys. It stands high above the River Seine, and it was meant to be a super-castle: a fortress on a commanding height over the river.

Within a few years it was under attack, and in the spring of 1204 it fell. How it fell is usually told as a long story of siege warfare. Here we focus on one well-sourced detail that is easy to overlook and hard to forget: the castle's weak spot was its toilet.

Engraving of Château Gaillard on its height above the Seine
Château Gaillard in a 19th-century engraving.Victor Adolphe Malte-Brun, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Medieval manuscript image of King Richard I
Richard I in a 13th-century manuscript.Unknown 13th-century artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In September 1203 the French king, Philip II, laid siege to Château Gaillard, and the siege dragged on into the following year. The full story of the siege is long. This page is about one detail of it, and a rather unglamorous one: the toilets.

Late medieval miniature showing the coronation of King Philip II of France
The coronation of Philip II (Philip Augustus), painted by Jean Fouquet in the Grandes Chroniques de France.Jean Fouquet, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

How a castle toilet worked

Castle toilets were called garderobes. A garderobe was a small chamber built into the wall, with a seat over a hole. Whatever went into the hole simply dropped down and came out on the outside of the wall. It was a simple arrangement that kept the waste away from the rooms inside, and surviving garderobes can still be seen in castle walls, like the two examples below.

Cross-section diagram of a garderobe: a seat in the castle wall over a hole, with waste dropping down the outside
The garderobe in cross-section: a seat inside the wall, and everything goes down to the outside.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)
Surviving garderobe chamber in the wall of Peveril Castle
A surviving garderobe at Peveril Castle, Derbyshire.Dave.Dunford, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Garderobe at Chirk Castle
A garderobe at Chirk Castle.Prichardson, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

That design has an obvious consequence. If waste can go down and out, there is a shaft. And a shaft that leads down to the outside also leads up, into the castle.

In through the latrines

Our account of what happened comes from Guillaume le Breton, the French king's chaplain, who was there as an eyewitness. According to him, a few soldiers got into the castle through the latrines situated under a chapel that adjoined the rampart. In other words, the attackers came in by way of the latrines.

Diagram showing a latrine shaft under a chapel, with an arrow pointing up the shaft into the castle
The weak spot: in through the latrines, under the chapel.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

It is worth being careful about what we do and do not know. The sources do not agree on the name of the soldier involved: he appears as Bogis, Boggis or Ralph. So this page leaves the name out and sticks to what le Breton reports: soldiers got in through the latrines under the chapel.

What the sources do not tell us

Popular retellings of this episode often add colour that the sources used here do not support, so this page deliberately leaves several things out. We do not describe how the intruders proceeded once they were inside, because that is not part of the evidence checked for this story. We do not call Château Gaillard the largest castle in France or use similar superlatives. And we say nothing about grilles in the shafts. What remains is the core the sources support: a siege that began in September 1203, a latrine route under a chapel reported by an eyewitness, and a castle that fell in March 1204.

Lionheart and LacklandKing Richard, King John and the wars of conquestAffiliate linkAmazon →

The fall of Château Gaillard

On 6 March 1204, Château Gaillard fell. Richard the Lionheart had built a super-castle high above the Seine, and according to the French king's own chaplain, one way in turned out to be the toilet.

📚 Want more?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fact check 5 claims
Château Gaillard was built by Richard the Lionheart in the 1190s above the SeineWikipedia, Château Gaillard (1196–1198, Les Andelys, above the Seine)
The siege by Philip II began in 1203 (September)Encyclopædia Universalis; Wikipedia, Siege of Château Gaillard
Soldiers got in through latrines under a chapel adjoining the wall, according to Guillaume le Breton (the king's chaplain, an eyewitness)Encyclopædia Universalis ("aux dires de le Breton, par des latrines situées sous une chapelle contiguë au rempart")
The castle fell in March 1204 (6 March)Wikipedia; Encyclopædia Universalis
Garderobe: a chamber in the wall, a seat over a hole, waste drops down the outside of the wallWorld History Encyclopedia, Toilets in a Medieval Castle; Wikipedia, Garderobe

Deliberately left out (evidence too thin): The name of the soldier (Bogis, Boggis or Ralph: the sources contradict each other), how the intruders proceeded once inside, superlatives such as "the largest castle in France", and grilles in the shafts.

Sources 3
  1. Encyclopædia Universalis, Siège de Château-Gaillard (1203-1204)
    https://www.universalis.fr/encyclopedie/siege-de-chateau-gaillard/
  2. Wikipedia, Siege of Château Gaillard
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Ch%C3%A2teau_Gaillard
  3. World History Encyclopedia, Toilets in a Medieval Castle
    https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1239/toilets-in-a-medieval-castle/