Hardly Dark Ages

Short 06 · 1070s–1500s (myth: 1902) · 3 min read

Spiral Stairs Weren't Built for Swords

You've been told castle stairs turn clockwise so the defender's sword arm wins. The oldest source for that is from 1902, not 1302.

The Short is coming soon on YouTube.📚 Books on this

The swordsman stair

It is one of the best-known castle stories. Spiral stairs in castles rise clockwise, so a defender coming down has his right, sword-carrying arm on the open, outer side of the stair, while an attacker climbing up has his right arm jammed against the central post, the newel. The castle researcher Neil Guy opens his survey of the subject by calling this the "traditional castle story" and an orthodoxy.

Painting of a stone spiral staircase inside Rochester Castle
William Holman Hunt, A staircase at Rochester Castle, Kent (19th century).William Holman Hunt, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Diagram of a clockwise spiral stair seen from above, with the defender's sword arm free and the attacker's sword arm cramped
The popular theory, seen from above: defender's sword arm free, attacker's sword arm cramped.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

The observation behind it is largely right. The explanation is the problem: no medieval source says that stairs were turned to favour a right-handed defender.

Where the idea comes from: 1902

The buildings archaeologist James Wright traced the earliest citation he could find to Theodore Andrea Cook, an art critic, journalist and sportsman. Cook was a serious fencer: he captained the English fencing team at the 1906 Athens Games, and according to Wright he founded the Oxford University Fencing Club in 1891.

In "The Shell of Leonardo", an essay on spiral forms in nature and architecture published in The Monthly Review in May 1902 (vol. 7, no. 20, p. 106), Cook writes that a man climbing a stair of one handedness would always have his right hand free to attack the defenders, while the garrison coming down would expose their left hands. The passage reappears in his book Spirals in Nature and Art (1903, p. 145), and on p. 139 he suggests a possible military reason for the stairs at Blarney Castle and Tantallon Castle.

Scanned page 106 of The Monthly Review, May 1902
Page 106 of The Monthly Review, May 1902, from Cook's essay "The Shell of Leonardo".The Monthly Review (May 1902), public domain, via Internet Archive

Two details matter. Cook was speculating from a fencer's point of view, not drawing on any medieval text or record of a fight. And he did not claim that stair direction in general was chosen for defence: in the same paragraph he says the more common type of spiral is probably more common because architects are usually right-handed. The neat universal rule came later. Wright shows how it spread through Guy Cadogan Rothery (1912) and the castle historian Sidney Toy (1939 and 1954).

What the buildings show

Most castle stairs do turn clockwise going up: Neil Guy notes that clockwise stairs predominate in the eleventh and twelfth centuries. But in "The Rise of the Anti-clockwise Newel Stair" (Castle Studies Group Journal 25, 2011–12) he recorded more than 85 anticlockwise spiral stairs in castles in England and Wales, dating from the 1070s to the 1500s.

Diagram comparing clockwise stairs (most of them) with anticlockwise stairs (85 plus) in castles in England and Wales
Most stairs turn clockwise, but Guy recorded more than 85 anticlockwise ones in England and Wales, 1070s–1500s.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

Some are in the most military buildings imaginable. In the White Tower at the Tower of London, the main stair in the north-east corner turns clockwise, but a second stair in the north-west corner turns anticlockwise; Guy suggests it may have been added to the plan around 1080. Anticlockwise stairs were used regularly in Edward I's castles in Wales in the late 13th century: at Caernarfon most of them are in the Eagle, Well and Chamberlain Towers, Conwy has one in the Bakehouse Tower, and Beaumaris and Caerphilly are also on the list.

Old print of the White Tower at the Tower of London
The White Tower, Tower of London. Anonymous print, Yale Center for British Art.Yale Center for British Art, CC0 / public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Nineteenth-century photograph of the interior of Caernarfon Castle looking towards the Eagle Tower
Caernarfon Castle, interior, looking towards the Eagle Tower. Photograph by Francis Bedford.Francis Bedford, LACMA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Historic Building MythbustingBy James Wright, whose research is one of the sources for this storyAffiliate linkAmazon →

Space, light and convenience

Guy's verdict is clear. There are enough anticlockwise examples to show that the choice depended on physical convenience and architectural practicalities, and there was no military ideology that demanded clockwise staircases. He also points to light sources, traffic flow (paired up and down stairs in gatehouses) and, later, simple fashion.

Diagram listing space, light and convenience as the deciding factors, with sword fights crossed out
What decided the direction, after Neil Guy: space, light and convenience, not sword fights.Diagram: Hardly Dark Ages (simplified)

Why clockwise stairs are still the majority remains open. Suggestions include the handedness of the builder, ease of climbing for right-handed people, lighting and layout constraints, but none of them is proven.

Fighting on the stairs?

There is also a practical problem with the theory. Wright found no medieval evidence of stair fights deciding a siege: sieges usually ended through starvation, threats, bribery, blunders or trickery. Guy puts it bluntly: the game was up before that stage could be reached. If the enemy is already on your stairs, the stairs are not your biggest problem.

Narrow stone spiral stair inside Clifford's Tower, York
Inside Clifford's Tower, York.HJ Mitchell, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (licence)

Some popular sites still argue that a clockwise stair gave defenders an advantage in practice. But nobody has produced a medieval source showing the builders intended it. The fair summary: the stairs mostly do turn clockwise, but the swordsman explanation is unsupported and contradicted by the buildings.

📚 Want more?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fact check 10 claims
Popular claim: spiral stairs turn clockwise going up so that right-handed defenders above have room to strikeGuy 2011–12, p. 114 (abstract: "traditional castle story"); Wright, Mythbusting Blog #3
The oldest known written version of the sword theory: Theodore Andrea Cook, 1902Primary source checked: Cook, "The Shell of Leonardo", The Monthly Review vol. 7 no. 20 (May 1902), p. 106 (archive.org scan); Wright (Blog #3 and 2024 book): earliest citation he found. In 1903 in the book Spirals in Nature and Art, pp. 139 and 145
Cook was an art critic and fencerWright (Blog #3: founder of the Oxford University Fencing Club 1891, fencing column in the Daily Telegraph); Wikipedia, "Theodore Andrea Cook" (captain of the English fencing team, Athens 1906; art critic); ODNB entry (Ian Buchanan) as reference
It was an essay on spiralsTitle and content checked directly (Monthly Review 1902; 1903 book: "study of spiral formations based on the manuscripts of Leonardo da Vinci")
Most castle stairs turn clockwiseGuy 2011–12, p. 163 ("clockwise stairs predominate in the eleventh and twelfth centuries"); Wright Blog #3 (Guy/Ryder: about 30% anticlockwise)
Neil Guy: more than 85 anticlockwise stairs in castles in England and Wales, 1070s to 1500sGuy 2011–12, p. 114 (abstract); Medievalists.net (2012) reports the same
Among them the Tower of London (White Tower, north-west stair, 1070s/1080)Guy p. 116; Wright Blog #3 (Tower of London, 11th century)
Among them Edward I's castles in Wales (Caernarfon, including the Eagle Tower; Conwy; Beaumaris)Guy pp. 137–138 and table; Wright Blog #3
Guy's conclusion: the direction depended on convenience and building conditions (space, light sources), not military doctrineGuy p. 163 ("physical convenience and architectural practicalities … no military ideology"), p. 138 (light); Wright Blog #3 (architectural decision, status symbol)
Fighting on the stairs means the defence is already lostGuy p. 116 ("the game obviously was up before that stage could be reached"); Wright Blog #3 (sieges ended through starvation, treachery etc., no recorded stair fights)

Deliberately left out (evidence too thin): The "30%" figure (only attested via Wright; Guy and Ryder's original count was not seen). Why exactly clockwise is more common: hypotheses such as right-handers carrying loads on the right with a hand on the rope on the left, the builder's handedness, or lighting are not established, so the script only gives Guy's verdict of "space, light and convenience". Cook's confusing terminology for the direction of turn and his speculation about Blarney and Tantallon (1903): too complicated for 40 seconds, kept in the research dossier. Ferniehirst and the "left-handed Kerrs": a separate myth. Films (Robin Hood 1938, The Princess Bride) as spreaders of the myth: only attested by Wright.

Sources 5
  1. Neil Guy, "The Rise of the Anti-clockwise Newel Stair", The Castle Studies Group Journal 25 (2011–12), pp. 113–173
  2. Theodore Andrea Cook, "The Shell of Leonardo", The Monthly Review 7/20 (May 1902), p. 106
    https://archive.org/details/sim_monthly-review-uk_1902-05_7_20
  3. Theodore Andrea Cook, Spirals in Nature and Art (London: John Murray, 1903), pp. 139, 145
    https://archive.org/details/spiralsinnaturea00cook
  4. James Wright, Historic Building Mythbusting (The History Press, 2024) · on Amazon (affiliate)
  5. James Wright, Mediaeval Mythbusting Blog #3, Triskele Heritage
    https://triskeleheritage.triskelepublishing.com/mediaeval-mythbusting-blog-2-the-man-who-invented-the-spiral-staircase-myth/